Ask the Schoolar
Ask The Scholar
Question Details


Question: Is it permissible to slaughter a male animal in Eid -ul azaha which had been castrated ?
Answer:
There is nothing wrong in sacrificing a castrated animal.
 
We read in the traditions that the Prophet sometimes sacrificed neutered animals, while, at other times, he chose those who were not.  Based on these precedents scholars have ruled that what is important is to sacrifice what is available for a person.
 
After reviewing the above precedents,  Imam Shawkani says: "There is no reason o prefer one type of animal over another since we have precedents for both in the practice of the Prophet (peace be upon him). However, while choosing for sacrifice the primary point to consider is the quality of the meat." 
Ask the Schoolar